A lot of people have made a lot of comparisons of the three next-gen consoles - price, games, fun factor, and even screen resolution have been compared, but I’ve got one more metric to throw out there. Price per “p” or the price per line of progressive-scan resolution. All three consoles seek to provide the most value to their customer. PS3 is high priced, but more featured. The Wii is the cheapest and has less technical prowess. Sitting somewhere in the middle seems to be the Xbox 360, or is it? Which system really delivers the most technical/graphical value for your gaming dollars? Hopefully with the price per “p” metric we can decide once and for all which system is the “best value”.
To start with the formula is very easy. Price per “p” is calculated as the price of the system divided by the lines of resolution it will output in progressive scan mode. I chose progressive numbers because those are easier to do a direct comparison on. The Wii supports up to 480p, the Xbox 360 supports 720p, and the PS3 supports 1080p. (note: the 360 now supports 1080p via an upscaler, but that is just upscaling the games’ native 720p resolution, so it’s not a fair comparison).
Based on the cheapest bundles, here are the scores:
Wii - 0.5208333 ($250/480p)
Xbox 360 - 0.4166666 ($300/720p)
PS3 - 0.4629629 ($500/1080p)
Based on the more expensive bundles, here are the scores:
Wii - 0.5208333 ($250/480p)
Xbox 360 - 0.5555555 ($400/720p)
PS3 - 0.5555555 ($600/1080p)
So, the best graphics value of the cheaper bundles is the Xbox 360 core system with a price per “p” of just under 42 cents per “p”. Surprisingly, the PS3 $500 edition beats the Wii in price per “p” by a few cents. However, looking at the full-priced systems the Wii gains the lead in graphics value again, which is no real surprise.
Now all of this is assuming that you have a HDTV, but what if you are among the 90+% of people who don’t have a HDTV? Then all you are getting is 480i or (240p by comparison), so a new calculation is needed:
Wii - 1.041666 ($250/240p)
Xbox 360 - 1.25 ($300/240p)
PS3 - 2.08333 ($500/240p)
Looking at how things fare on a SDTV, which is still the standard for the vast majority of video gamers, the value proposition for the next gen is completely different. The Wii wins hands down.
In conclusion, the Xbox 360 is the best HDTV value and the Wii is the best SDTV value, but before you start arguing some of the finer points of this comparison, I’ll head them off right now. Yes, I realize that the PS3 game library will be mostly 720p and not 1080p, but even giving the PS3 the benefit of the doubt in the 1080p arena doesn’t make it that much better of a value. Also, the Wii is bundled with a game and the other systems are not, so it’s probably an even better value than the numbers show.
Just for kicks, let’s calculate what the numbers would be for the 360 doing 1080p. The scores would be 27.777 cents per “p” for the 360 Core and 37.037 cents per “p” for the 360 Premium. For you 1080p users out there that makes the 360 a WAY better deal than the PS3.